Are We Like Disappointed
Surfers?
When the surfers in the movie got to their destinations, the
waves weren’t always the best. They either waited till the weather
whipped up the surf, or moved on to the next destination. Surfers,
you see are dependent on the whims of Neptune to produce the
waves.
In business, we are also dependent on the
"waves" if we depend only on the economy, or the health of a
single market segment like the languishing industrial market. Like
expectant surfers, most businesses are reactive. They stick to a
couple of beaches, and hope for the best. The boys from The Endless
Summer were pretty creative in one sense, though, going where the
surf was best at different times during the year. But what if
none of the beaches offered any really nice waves to ride for
a considerable time? Our surfers would be sorely
disappointed.
Did Too Many "Waves" Cloud Our
Vision?
From 1993 through mid 2000, maybe we became complacent
in our efforts to create significant new value-added offerings to
customers because plenty of "waves" kept coming our way. And
because of that, maybe we didn’t put enough emphasis on R&D and
creating new, significant value added products and services by
performing solid market research that discovered latent customer
needs or looked forward in time to identify legislative, code, or
technology convergence trends that would lead to “new product or
service opportunities”.
Maybe we did some of this, but not enough, because when the
wind died down, the waves diminished, and we were left like
disappointed surfers, gazing out over the horizon in anticipation of
the next big swell.
Cut Costs?
With a perceived lack of market upside, almost everything you
read about these days says to cut costs during these times. Well,
duh! My gut always tells me to do the opposite, though.
No, don't ignore intelligent cost reductions, but
actually INVEST more in R&D that will either get you a
competitive advantage in value added, or increase the demand for the
kinds of product or new products you could develop. One of
Marketing's key objectives should be to create increased usage or
greater value to command more of the buyer's available dollars.
Today, you are in competition with more than competitors in your
narrow product category. With suddenly more scarce discretionary
dollars, you are competing with just about anything on which a
customer would spend their suddenly much dearer dollars.
The Recovery is right around the
Corner...
That's a typical hopeful response (Excuse?). But, the only
thing that's around the corner may be more of the same.
We asked distributors and manufacturers about their
2002 sales results at the recent Region 1 NAED conference.
The results were mediocre for most. The prevailing feeling for
2003 was that nobody expected the market to get much better. They're
probably right, given the news from the experts:
-
The Economy: 3% Gross Domestic Product (GDP) Growth
(McGraw-Hill, NAHB, NABE)
-
Residential Market: Housing starts will decline 3.5%
(NAHB)
-
Construction: Construction Spending will drop 1%
(McGraw Hill) Lowlight: Office construction will be down another
8% beyond last year's 29% decline.
-
Industrial: Capital spending may increase 5%,
offsetting last year's 5% decline, which was depressed anyway.
We've been in a seven quarter decline in capital spending, the
longest in NABE's 21 year
history of tracking it. Risk: war may squelch capital spending
recovery in all but defense-related
industries.
 |
DISC Corporation's
Herm Isenstein forecasts a very flat scenario from
2000-2006, and no real significant recovery until 2005. These
numbers are not deflated, so if they were, things would
probably look negative. But, what manufacturer is seeing
realized price increases anyway? |
|
If you're
wondering how the total can be 1.4%, while contractor and
industrial are slightly lower, the difference is made up by
the smaller commercial & institutional user and utility
markets.
For more details,
visit www.disccorp.com.
Isenstein has other products to find pockets of more
attractive segment or geographical growth. Check it
out. |
Dawn on The Horizon
OK, so
things take time to be understood in this industry. But they
are being understood pretty clearly now, after nearly three years of
poor economic performance. We’ve been in an economic funk long
enough to give up the hope that another big “wave” will save us.
However, I’m sensing that a light is going on in the minds of
a few of those we spoke with. They are starting to pay attention to
some "back to basics" strategy elements.
Three Legs of The "Back To Basics"
Stool
-
New Value Propositions Companies
are reviewing the mix of products and services offered by market
segment. They are looking at where the opportunities are, how they
are positioned vs competition on price, value and features, what
they should do to improve their offerings, how to get in touch
with customers to discover new features, products or services to
offer. They plan well out into the future, identifying external
"trigger points" that signal when it is time to release a new set
of product features or services.
-
Focused Field Market
Planning Smart distributors and manufacturers are
creating market catalogs, reviewing not just sales and share, but
share of all possible customers in each territory, who they want
to sell more to, which new business opportunities they want,
setting sales and share goals, and measuring results by trading
area. Manufacturers are taking a hard look at distribution
authorization planning this way, too.
-
Compensation Alignment It's not enough to focus on new
opportunities at headquarters. And surprisingly, a new value
proposition won't help much either in a market where personal
selling is eighty percent or more of your communications. You have
to change the incentive.
IRCG Principal Mike Marks recently
reminded me that most people will do things to get out of pain
vs. doing things because they're the right strategy for the
company. Accordingly, change your compensation plan to reward
sales people for doing the new things you need them to do. Salary
and bonus plans generally work much better than commission plans
in this regard. Why? You're in control, not the troops. Sun Tzu
once said: "If your troops are at the river and they have the
alternative to board their ships and retreat, burn the ships and
they will stand and fight."
When you think of it, #1 is how you make your own
waves, and #2 is your surfboard, because #1 rides your sales
force (and distribution if you are a manufacturer) to shore. But # 3
is what gets your sales force to focus on accomplishing the new
things management requires of them.
Keep it Up
If you’re going to generate your own waves, you need
to keep at it regularly because waves have their own lifecycle, and
it's not under your control. If the economic climate is
robust, another one is always coming along, so you don’t have to
worry. The opposite is also true!
When you shift from an opportunistic mode to the game of
providing superior value added, you need to stay on top of emerging
trends that will affect your customer’s needs, and you need to
create a formal, ongoing methodology to involve your
customers in the creation of new features, products and
services.
Make Your Own Waves
If the waves aren't being whipped up by Neptune, make
your own. Focus on distinct end user and channel marketing
opportunities, and get closer to the customer as your partner in new
product and service design. Finally, make sure you have the right
incentive program to drive the new behaviors you deem
necessary.
If the waves aren't coming to us, we've got to be more
focused and productive at spotting and developing THEM.
Neil
Gillespie
Gillespie is a principal and co-founder
of Channel Marketing Group |
Let’s Put
New Plays in our Playbook
Bill Marshall
Corporate VP Marketing
Leviton Manufacturing Company
It would seem that the
economy, our experience of the past two years, and the declining
bottom line seen from both the distributor’s and manufacturer’s
perspectives should motivate us all to concentrate more energy on
our strategic sales and marketing plans.
For those who are regulars at the planning table, the
question is usually what went well the past year, what should we be
doing more of and what should be eliminated. Unfortunately,
many times we simply recast what we did rather than thinking of
what would best suit our longer term plans. For those that
haven’t grabbed a seat at the planning table – we should all work
out a plan for THIS coming year. And we need to ask ourselves
“why aren’t we planning? Why the delay? Looking around,
listening, reading, nearly everything points in 2003 to at best –
slow growth, a continued decline in employment and flat capital
spending in the first six months of 2003. Basically
mimicking much of what we have experienced in
2002.
Circumstances like these make for an ideal environment to
focus on MARKETING and SALES PLANNING. The two go hand in
hand. It is easy to hit goals when the economy is humming along –
challenging times call for some new plays in our business
playbooks.
These economic indicators cry for a game plan to help us hold
what we have and grow in those few encouraging areas where growth is
possible. In those bright spots are we prepared to
differentiate ourselves from others that service and sell the health
care, education, the single family home construction and existing
home renovation markets? Do we know what is necessary to
differentiate ourselves from these markets current suppliers?
What process for prospecting new accounts do we have? How do we
measure our sales folks effectiveness?
The type of programs needed to grow, effect some turnaround
or simply stop a slide are really not that hard to put together if
we focus our combined resources. It’s not a lack of
ability…it’s more the inability to make the time.
Manufacturers continue to have a
desire to invest their varied resources in growth opportunities but
these times have made us more keenly focused on investing in
business plans that offer roadmaps to growth, with measurement of
those plans. It has become the reasonable, de-facto
yardstick to measure these investments (co-op, promotional, other
incentives) a.k.a. “funding”, on an ROI basis of incremental sales
and margin contribution.
Building Integrated Marketing & Sales plans is one of the
most important things we should be doing in any times…but certainly
now. As important as this is, it is profitable for both parties, can
be downright fun and helps us both bring our relationships and
abilities to higher, more professional levels.
It will define our real business partnerships, so let’s do it
more and better than before. |